Insurers as claimants in polluter pays litigation? Subrogation, attribution science and beyond

Polluter pays litigation has emerged as a potential avenue to pursue corporate accountability for climate change. Now, through the doctrine of subrogation, insurers, who increasingly bear the costs of climate impacts, may extend these claims beyond suing public bodies and utilities for failing to adapt to target high-emitting actors for their contribution to the harm itself. Although serious legal and institutional obstacles remain, from a scientific perspective assembling claims may be more straightforward for insurers than for current claimants – as Nicholas Petkov, Zaneta Sedilekova, Viktor Roezer and Jameela Joy Reyes argue.
The matter of whether greenhouse gas emitters could ever be held liable for the impacts of their emissions from the perspective of rising insurance premia was raised as far back as 2003 by Myles Allen. He argued that as climate change raises flood risk, insurance costs may rise and house prices may fall. Some of this financial loss could therefore be attributed to the companies and industries emitting greenhouse gases.
Since then, over 40 claims have been filed with courts worldwide seeking damages from high-emitting companies because of climate-induced or anticipated harm. Known as ‘systemic polluter pays’ cases, these claims have primarily focused on the role and responsibility of fossil-fuel producers – with one recent case (Kennedy v. Exxon Mobil Corp.) also addressing producers’ responsibility for rising home insurance premia. Attribution science, the field of climate science that seeks to understand the influence of anthropogenic emissions on the climate, is increasingly used to support these compensation claims, which to date have primarily been filed strategically with support from non-governmental organisations, or by cities and municipalities in the United States.
Changing trends in subrogation
Although insurance has not played a central role in polluter pays cases to date, it could well do in the future. Climate change presents a serious challenge for insurers, having directly cost the industry between US$475 and 720 billion globally in the 20 years to 2022, an amount that is projected to rise in the coming years.
One route by which insurers could recover some of these costs is subrogation. Subrogation is the legal doctrine that allows an insurer, once it has paid out against a policyholder’s claim, to ‘step into the shoes’ of the policyholder and pursue a third party whose fault caused or contributed to the loss. In the climate change context, this could, in theory, allow insurers to seek recovery from parties they argue failed to prevent climate-related damage or contributed to it.
Insurance cases filed to date that hinge on these arguments have mostly involved insurers acting against state governments, municipalities and utilities. One instance is Illinois Farmers Insurance Co. v. Metropolitan Water Reclamation District of Greater Chicago. After heavy rainfall in April 2013 caused sewer backups and flooding in the Chicago area, Farmers Insurance sought damages from local municipalities and water districts. They argued that the defendants knew, including from their own climate action plans, that climate change was making heavy rainfall more frequent but that they had failed to increase stormwater and sewer capacity in response. The claims were abruptly withdrawn in 2014.
A recent notable development is Tokio Marine and Nichido Fire Insurance v. Transnet and others (2025). Two insurance companies that had to pay out to businesses following flooding in 2022 in the Durban area of South Africa have taken legal action against local municipalities and a state-owned transport company. The insurers argue that these entities were negligent in maintaining stormwater infrastructure, which in turn amplified the scale of the loss arising from the disaster. Although the defendants are responsible for infrastructure, attribution studies have found that climate change played a pronounced role in the floods, adding a clear climate dimension to the claim. Thus, the claim engages the insurers as stakeholders in litigation around weather events and raises important issues about state-level responsibility for climate adaptation.
One crucial challenge in the Tokio Marine case is the scale of the claim. The claimants are seeking R6.5 billion (US$368.4 million) in damages, a figure that roughly equates to the municipality’s capital infrastructure budget for 2026/27 (R6.3 billion). This is a revealing comparison. If such claims are successful, localities with limited infrastructure budgets could see a vicious cycle of damages claims. Insurers would also be left with limited recourse to recover losses arising from climate damage if they only pursue budget-constrained local actors.
Thus, as losses mount, insurers may extend subrogation claims beyond suing public bodies and utilities for failing to adapt to target high-emitting actors for contributing to the cause of the harm itself. We break down how this shift may look from two perspectives: legal and institutional, and scientific.
A legal and institutional perspective on a possible shift in subrogation…
Significant legal and institutional challenges are present in existing polluter pays cases. These include establishing a basis for liability, proving causation across the entire chain, and allocating responsibility among multiple contributors. Financial and resource constraints on the part of claimants also come into play, as well as political resistance and fragmented regulatory landscapes.
While insurers could initiate polluter pays cases against high emitters through the vehicle of subrogation, to our knowledge, no such cases have been brought to date – and we have identified three possible reasons why.
First, in subrogation, insurers derive from the insured party their rights to claim compensation from a third party (the polluter); therefore, the insurer has no greater rights than the insured party. That means that a subrogated claim is only as good as the ‘underlying’ claim which a party would have against someone who has injured them. As long as the outcome of systemic polluter pays claims remains uncertain, whether due to scientific or legal questions, insurers are unlikely to view subrogated actions as a sufficiently reliable way to recover their losses.
Second, even if barriers to systemic polluter pays claims are overcome, allowing subrogation to become a more attractive recovery strategy, the structure of the insurance market may create conflicts of interest that discourage insurers from pursuing such claims systematically. A subrogated claim against a polluter is likely to involve insurers on both sides: for instance, a first-party property insurer seeking to recover payments made to policyholders who suffered climate-related losses, and a third-party liability insurer covering the polluter against the alleged liability. These insurers may already be connected through various commercial arrangements, including operating within the same insurance group, or having a reinsurance relationship. Such existing relationships may create conflicts of interest and discourage insurers from initiating subrogated climate-damages claims in the first place.
Finally, the relationship between insurance and fossil fuel industries may provide an additional reason for insurers’ reluctance to pursue subrogated claims (though the evidence here is as yet thin). As part of the investment side of their business, which exists alongside their underwriting business, many insurers hold considerable investments in the oil and gas sector. The gains they would make in subrogated recoveries against polluters on the underwriting side of their business may therefore create losses on the investment side of their business.
…and a scientific perspective
From a scientific perspective, polluter pays claims may be easier to pursue with insurers as claimants – and again, we see three possible reasons why.
The first is related to tracing impact. Insurers may be better placed to understand, evidence and quantify damage. Insurers can easily collect data about the impacts of a particular weather event and the claimed-for damage is easy to quantify as it is calculated as all or some proportion of settlements paid out that arise from the impacts of climate change. Not only can insurers collect data about impacts of specific weather events but often they already have comprehensive databases of past claims. That data is crucial to developing further scientific modelling capabilities and could be used to attribute the share of the growing insured damage that is caused by climate change.
In Kennedy v. Exxon Mobil, for example, the claimant’s request is for current and quantifiable financial losses (i.e. the elevated premia that claimants are paying now), rather than future or projected losses related to physical climate impacts. This loss may be more concrete and easier to quantify than the losses pursued in other polluter pays claims.
Second, when it comes to aggregating damage, insurers can combine damage data across large geographical areas, making it easier to use climate attribution science to identify the role of climate change than it would be for individual claimants. This helps overcome a challenge that may be faced by individuals or smaller scale defendants seeking to use attribution science to prove damage in polluter pays litigation. While impact attribution (the field of attribution science that quantifies and assesses the relative contribution of climate change to climate impacts) can assess economic damage across an entire city or country, it cannot calculate whether a specific house would have been damaged. For instance, a 2021 study of Hurricane Sandy found that approximately US$8.1 billion of the hurricane’s damage to the East Coast of the United States was attributable to climate-mediated anthropogenic sea level rise. This attribution finding may more adequately reflect the losses of insurers than individuals.
Finally, insurers may have better capacity than other claimants to utilise existing expertise and grapple with the complex scientific arguments required to build claims. Research has found that climate litigation often does not incorporate the latest scientific evidence. Meanwhile, climate science and modelling are used and relied upon by the insurance industry: large insurers and reinsurers have a history of hiring scientific experts and funding internal research departments to better understand the risks they might end up insuring, including those from weather- and climate-related events. While some of the insights used to make decisions about whether a risk can be insured or not are based on information that are in the public domain (for example, in scientific publications), insurers are increasingly relying on private research and risk analysis. Combining public and private research could inform climate litigation cases to a degree that is currently not possible when solely relying on scientific findings in the public domain.
Looking to the future
Together these scientific perspectives may challenge the ‘underlying claim’ argument. If systemic polluter pays claims are easier for insurers to construct, they may overcome barriers that prevent existing cases from succeeding. But we must not forget the institutional and legal barriers that constrain the involvement of the insurance industry – navigating legal standards of causation and responsibility and the organisational structure of the industry represent core challenges. Subrogated polluter pays cases would represent a shift from traditional strategic polluter pays litigation to litigation as a viable recovery avenue for insurers.
While academic research in this field is slowly emerging, this issue remains only partially understood, and future research will need to combine legal, scientific and insurance perspectives. Nonetheless, through subrogation or otherwise, insurers are certainly set to become crucial stakeholders in the global response to climate change.
The authors would like to thank Noah Walker-Crawford, Tiffanie Chan and Lucia Williams for reviewing this commentary.