Returning to London from Antalya, Nick Godfrey sets down his thoughts on what he learnt at COP 31, from the positive real-economy changes often obscured by ‘doom and gloom’ reporting, to the added support needed for Finance Ministries grappling with fossil fuel phaseout, to a growing number of ‘Coalitions of the Working’.

After attending the first week of COP 31, I am filled with a mixture of frustration and optimism. Below I provide some personal reflections from attending side-events, speaking to delegates and following the press reporting. 

The good

Contrary to the gloomy impression from some commentators, I saw continuing strong momentum by many countries who are getting on with the job of implementing their commitments to transforming their economies onto a net zero pathway.

From Nigeria to China and Burundi, we saw countries reaffirming their pledges, mainly because they see it is in their self-interest to do so. I felt incredible energy in so many of the pavilions, with ever more inspiring plans for green industrial transformation and the use of new technologies on show. China’s green economy is now worth over 10% of GDP backed by targeted incentives schemes and government guided investment funds.

The Brazilian Presidency – ever impressive in its energy – released the three roadmaps it promised on phasing out fossil fuels, arresting deforestation and catalysing investment to meet the $1.3 trillion per year required in emerging markets and developing countries. For the first time this roadmap contains a major focus on the role of finance ministries in transforming the entire system of financing and on ways to reduce the cost of capital in emerging markets and developing countries.

In short: don’t buy into the doom and gloom. Beyond the negotiations there are positive, tangible real-economy changes happening.

The bad

However, the funding landscape is still quite depressing. Many governments have reversed their ambitious commitments to fund major partnerships with key actors and countries capable of driving the transition at an even greater pace and scale. The forests of the world, for example, are the lungs of the world, so the short-sighted nature of some governments in reversing commitments to protect these vital assets feels indefensible. Kudos to nations such as Norway that have remained firmly in the leadership seat.

There also continues to be a demonisation of certain major fossil fuel producer countries within the international climate community which feels unhelpful. Transitioning an economy reliant on ready oil and gas revenues is not easy. And it’s becoming ever clearer how little major international funders have done to assist producers to identify viable alternative development pathways while recognising their own role in consumption.

One notable ray of light here is the Beyond Oil and Gas Alliance’s Major Producers Dialogues, which bring together producers and non-producers to help plot viable routes forward in recognition of the structural decline the industry faces as we electrify. Another is the work the Coalition of Finance Ministers for Climate Action is doing in upgrading its flagship guide which shows that countries from Oman to UAE and Chile are making major changes to reimagine their economies and tax systems for a post-fossil fuel era – setting examples for others to follow.

The ugly

The evidence on climate change impacts looks ever more troubling.

It is hard to understand why certain political leaders still cannot fully grasp the basic science, which is as debatable as the law of gravity. There is a point at which the combination of increased heat and humidity simply makes human survival impossible and the global community is quickly moving towards placing several regions of the world in this territory.

As Levent Kurnaz, the imminent Turkish climate scientist, put so well, we are like a frog slowly heating up in water – failing to notice the danger until it becomes lethal.

Fortunately, there is now a step change in attention being given to adaptation and resilience where the economic and wider case for investment is so strong. And there continues to be strong recognition by many countries that climate action can be a powerful development opportunity.

The hope

An amazing group of what Nick Stern calls ‘Coalitions of the Working’ or the ‘Willing to Work’ is, fortunately, proliferating. These are smaller groups of major countries or sector movers who are willing to roll up their sleeves and make progress to complement the multilateral process. They include the Coalition of Finance Ministers for Climate Action – a group of now 100-plus Finance Ministers committed to doing more, three complementary regional platforms of Finance Ministries in Latin America, Africa and Asia, and the Vulnerable (20) Group of Finance Ministries.

We need more of these types of groupings which can vary in size depending on the issue in question – from tackling issues such as critical mineral supply chains to protecting the vital ecosystems prone to tipping points and which are too big to fail.

Possibly the most significant hope comes from the vibrant and growing community of climate actors now encouraging a more collaborative and mindful approach to leadership, drawing on Eastern traditions of loving kindness and deep listening as the basis for transforming the conversation from division to common understanding.

In the end, as we are all just human beings living on a common planet we call home, what other approach is there?

Keep in touch with the Grantham Research Institute at LSE
Sign up to our newsletters and get the latest analysis, research, commentary and details of upcoming events.