Working Paper 6


We estimate the impacts of an energy tax – the Climate Change Levy (CCL) – on the manufacturing sector using panel data from the UK production census.

Our identification strategy builds on the comparison of trends in outcomes between plants subject to the CCL and plants that were granted an 80 per cent discount on the levy after joining a so-called Climate Change Agreement (CCA).

Since the CCAs stipulate specific targets for energy usage or carbon emissions, this comparison yields a lower bound on the impact of the discount.

To address a likely selection endogeneity in CCA participation, we adopt an IV approach that exploits exogenous variation in pollution discharges that determined eligibility for CCA participation.

We find robust evidence that CCA participation had a strong positive impact on growth in both energy intensity and energy expenditures.

An analysis of fuel choices at the plant level reveals that this effect is mainly driven by stronger growth in electricity use and translates into a positive impact on CO2 emissions.

We do not find any statistically significant impacts of the tax on employment, gross output or total factor productivity.

We conclude that, had the CCL been implemented at full rate for all businesses, further cuts in energy use of substantial magnitude could have been achieved without jeopardising economic performance.

Ralf Martin, Laure B. de Preux and Ulrich J. Wagner

Keep in touch with the Grantham Research Institute at LSE
Sign up to our newsletters and get the latest analysis, research, commentary and details of upcoming events.