Who’s asking whom? Gendering in parliamentary interactions
How does gender shape who gets asked what in parliament?
In a new article for the British Journal of Political Science, Professor in Global Politics Denisa Kostovicova and Fellow in Conflict and Post-Conflict Studies Dr Vesna Popovski, with co-authors Dr Lanabi La Lova and Dr Tolga Sinmazdemir, examine the interactive nature of parliamentary speech. Analysing more than 2,500 exchanges in the Croatian Parliament between 2004 and 2020, they find that male MPs ask female ministers fewer and shorter questions than male ministers and engage in shorter exchanges with women than with men. Female MPs partially replicate this pattern, asking shorter questions of female ministers. Female ministers, however, were found to use their executive status to assert authority, giving longer responses than their male counterparts.
While the dominant view in research on parliaments equates male dominance with talking more, the authors argue that withholding speech is also a form of power. Limiting engagement with women can marginalise them, reproducing parliaments as masculine institutions with consequences for the quality of government oversight. These patterns hold after accounting for a range of controls such as MP seniority, question topic, leadership roles, and ideology. Their findings have implications for parliaments with similar question formats to Croatia’s, such as the UK’s.

Abstract
"Male domination is asserted and reproduced through speaking behavior in parliaments. We address the enduring challenge of women’s marginalization by examining the interactive nature of speech. People adjust their speaking behavior based on the gender and status of those with whom they interact. Analyzing over 2,500 question-and-answer sequences in the Croatian Parliament (2004–20), we identify interactional asymmetry: male MPs ask fewer and shorter questions of female ministers than of male ministers, and engage in shorter exchanges with women than with men. Notably, female MPs partially replicate this pattern, posing shorter questions to female ministers. Female ministers, however, use their executive status to assert authority and respond with longer answers than men, despite their marginalization as women. We reveal how non-cooperation through withholding speech and limiting engagement with women operates as a form of power in interactions, reproducing parliaments as masculine institutions whilst affecting the quality of government oversight."
Read the full journal article