Authors: Dr Mireia Borrell-Porta, Dr Kerris Cooper, Dr Joan Costa-Font, Dr Chiara Orsini,
Dr Berkay Ozcan (Team Leader), Professor Lucinda Platt (Senior Advisor)
Scope and Approach
This report sheds light on those factors associated with child outcomes across multiple domains of their lives: health, cognition and education, behaviour and social relationships. It covers these outcomes across children in England’s early years up to the end of primary school, using the Millennium Cohort Study. It enhances our understanding of family and individual factors linked to positive child outcomes across these domains in a number of ways.
- First, by considering all four domains side by side, it enables an overview and direct comparison of the most relevant factors across these domains as well as those that are specific to particular outcomes.
- Second, it uses multiple indicators for each of the four outcome domains and investigates them at three ages, 5, 7 and 11.
- Third, the choice of potential factors linked to these outcomes was informed by a literature review which enabled us to select those most relevant to each particular outcome
- Fourth, the report is based on rigorous empirical analysis, which employs multiple tests for the robustness of the associations between our specified factors and the child outcomes.
Overall we found a small number of highly robust relationships, many of which persisted across all three child ages. These are summarized for each indicator across the four outcome domains:
Health: BMI / overweight
- Maternal weight before pregnancy and maternal BMI at age nine months were consistent predictors of higher BMI and of an increased risk of overweight in children.
- While the effect sizes were not large once other factors were controlled for they were robust and persisted up to age 11, though maternal weight before pregnancy was a strong predictor only for girls.
- Smoking during pregnancy was also associated with higher risks of overweight at ages 7 and 11, revealing the potential long-run impacts of pre-natal and early childhood behaviours.
- While a range of other predictors were associated in some analyses and at some ages none of the other findings ‘survived’ all our additional tests.
Health: Self-Reported Child Health
- We found consistent negative effects on health from low birth weight and being of Pakistani or Bangladeshi ethnic origin.
- Higher income was associated with better health at age 11.
- Being picked on by other children or being bullied was consistently associated with worse health.
- Again, a number of other variables were significant in some models and at certain ages, and so may have some policy relevance, but these other findings were not fully robust to all additional tests.
Cognitive (verbal and non-verbal tests, ages 5, 7, 11) and educational (KS2 (age 11) maths and English)
- We identified a female advantage in the age 5 verbal and non-verbal tests and for verbal tests at age7. But by age 11 this advantage in cognitive tests was no longer present. However, on KS2 scores, girls performed better in English and Reading and worse in maths and arithmetic. These findings were robust to our additional tests.
- Having a mother who worked at age nine months had a consistently negative independent association with cognitive outcomes at ages 7 and 11, though interestingly not at age 5.
- Similarly, low income had a consistent effect on cognitive outcomes at ages 7 and 11.
- Maternal education mattered for all cognitive outcomes at all ages, with lower maternal education being associated with poorer cognitive outcomes. Maternal education was also associated with KS2 English and reading scores but, interestingly, not maths and arithmetic.
- Breastfeeding up to 6 months was also robustly associated with all cognitive and educational outcomes at ages 7 and 11.
Behaviour: total difficulties; externalising and internalising problems, hyperactivity
- Mother’s mental health was negatively associated with all behavioural outcomes. Although the size of the effects is not large, the associations are highly consistent.
- Maternal education was also significantly associated with total difficulties at all ages, while having more siblings was associated with fewer problems. Again these were highly consistent findings that survived the most stringent tests.
- The analysis shows how many factors that have a bearing on child outcomes are in fact interlinked.
- In addition, the findings demonstrate the importance of parental behaviours and family characteristics from early childhood - or even from before birth - for outcomes 6 to10 years down the line.
- The findings reinforce some of the associations that were clear from the earlier PREview study, such as the importance of maternal mental health for behavioural outcomes and of maternal education and family income for a range of outcomes. They show that these associations persist from the very early years to the end of primary school.
- Finally, it is important to recognise that in many cases, even if the associations are clear-cut, they only go a small way to explaining the great diversity in outcomes across children. Children differ in multiple ways for reasons that we cannot capture, and even the strongest relationships are not deterministic.
Download the Executive Summary (PDF)
Download the literature review here (PDF)
Download the full analytical report here (PDF)
Download the data tables here (Zipped file)
These reports have been produced with the support of the National Child and Maternal Health Intelligence Network, Public Health England.
Public Health England exists to protect and improve the nation’s health and wellbeing, and reduce health inequalities. We do this through world-leading science, knowledge and intelligence, advocacy, partnerships and providing specialist public health services. We are an executive agency of the Department of Health and Social Care, and a distinct organisation with operational autonomy. We provide government, local government, the NHS, Parliament, industry and the public with evidence-based professional, scientific expertise and support. Follow us on Twitter and Facebook.
The National Child and Maternal Intelligence Network is hosted and facilitated by PHE and provides wide-ranging, authoritative data, evidence and practice in relation to child and maternal health which you can use to improve the quality of care and outcomes for communities, patients and their families.
While this report has been developed in collaboration with PHE, the opinions and views expressed in it are those of the designated authors and do not necessarily reflect the opinions or views of PHE or any other part of government.